Should Athiests refrain from mockery for tactical reasons?
Anyone who knows me can probably guess my answer to that question. (For those of you who don't, it's "No". See here , here , here , and here for starters.). Amanda Marcotte has a lengthy post on Pandagon addressing this very issue (in response to this post on Echidne ). Her conclusion is that atheists would be stupid to surrender so powerful a tool as mockery, especially when it is used so effectively by others: I know, it made me cringe to type it, but it’s a very real fact and we have to face the truth. The entire reason that the right wing in America is so powerful today is because they use ridicule so frequently. The jokes don’t even have to be funny to be effective. Believe you and me, I know a lot of wingnuts and when they mock liberals, it’s often a fairly grim exercise. The entire phenomenon of “I’m not a feminist, but” exists strictly because anti-feminists refuse to argue with feminists so much as make jokes that are often more exercises in grim, unfun