A pessimistic take on Iraq
Here's General Odom (HT: Heraldblog) with his six brutal truths about Iraq:
Truth No. 1: No "deal" of any kind can be made among the warring parties in Iraq that will bring stability and order, even temporarily.Go read the article for more details.
Truth No. 2: There was no way to have "done it right" in Iraq so that U.S. war aims could have been achieved.
Truth No. 3: The theory that "we broke it and therefore we own it," with all the moral baggage it implies, is simply untrue because it is not within U.S. power to "fix it." [I'm glad to hear he thinks the "Pottery Barn" rule is bunk. So do I.]
Truth No. 4: The demand that the administration engage Iran and Syria directly, asking them to help stabilize Iraq, is patently naïve or cynically irresponsible until American forces begin withdrawing – and rapidly – so that there is no ambiguity about their complete and total departure.
Truth No. 5: The United States cannot prevent Iran from acquiring nuclear weapons.
Truth No. 6: It is simply not possible to prevent more tragic Iraqi deaths in Iraq.
Comments